Why Are Underride Crashes So Dangerous?
Underride accidents can be especially dangerous because they can bypass the passenger vehicle’s protective structure. In an IIHS study of 115 crashes involving passenger vehicles striking the backs of heavy trucks or semitrailers, nearly half of the vehicles sustained severe underride damage; those vehicles accounted for 23 of the 28 fatal crashes studied.
The resulting harm can include:
What Does Federal Law Require?
Federal safety standards address some types of underride protection, but not all. Rear underride guards are required on most qualifying trailers and semitrailers, while side and front underride protection are not currently subject to comparable federal requirements. Understanding what the law requires—and what it doesn’t—can be important when investigating how an underride crash happened.
What Is an Underride Guard?
An underride guard is a strong metal structure attached to the back of a truck or trailer. It is designed to stop a passenger vehicle from sliding underneath the trailer in a rear-end crash.
Federal safety standards require qualifying trailers and semitrailers to have rear underride protection. FMVSS 223 sets performance requirements for the guard itself, while FMVSS 224 establishes requirements for rear impact protection.
What Is a Mansfield Bar?
You may also hear a rear underride guard called a Mansfield bar. “Mansfield bar” is simply a common name for a rear underride guard, not a separate federal safety standard. The nickname dates to actress Jayne Mansfield’s death in a 1967 crash involving a tractor-trailer, which helped draw attention to the dangers of vehicles sliding underneath trucks.
Does a Rear Underride Guard Always Prevent an Underride Crash?
No. Federal requirements establish minimum performance standards, but they do not guarantee that a guard will prevent underride in every possible collision.
Speed, impact angle, the amount of overlap between the vehicles, vehicle height, guard design, and the forces involved can all affect whether an underride guard performs as intended.
The condition of the equipment matters, too. A guard that is missing, damaged, improperly attached, or inadequately maintained can raise different questions from one that was properly installed and maintained.
Does Federal Law Require Side Underride Guards?
Unlike rear underride guards, side underride guards are not currently required by federal law on most commercial trailers. NHTSA has studied whether they should be required and is considering possible regulatory action.
The Stop Underrides Act 2.0, introduced in 2026, proposes federal performance standards for side, rear, and front underride protection. The bill has been introduced but is not currently law.
The absence of a side guard does not automatically mean someone was negligent. Liability depends on the facts of the crash, the applicable law, and evidence showing what caused the collision and resulting harm.
Was the Underride Guard in Working Condition?
Investigating an underride crash may require more than looking at a photograph and asking whether a bar was present. Investigators may need to determine:
- What type of guard was installed?
- Whether the trailer was subject to the applicable federal requirements.
- Whether the guard was properly attached.
- Whether it had been damaged or improperly repaired.
- Whether maintenance and inspection requirements were followed.
- Whether the guard’s design or condition contributed to the extent of the underride.
- Whether the crash circumstances exceeded the guard’s intended performance.
Those details can become important evidence in determining whether someone else’s negligence contributed to the crash.