DeVaughn James Injury Lawyers
  • Home
    • DeVaughn James – East Wichita
    • DeVaughn James – West Wichita
    • DeVaughn James – Topeka
  • Practice Areas
    • Car Accidents
    • Trucking Accident
    • Motorcycle Accidents
    • Slip and Fall Injuries
    • Commercial Vehicle Accident
    • Brain Injuries
    • Dog Bite
    • Drunk Driving
    • Product Injuries
    • Nursing Home Injuries
    • Roundup Cancer Lawsuit
    • Workers Compensation
    • Wrongful Death
    • Bad Drugs & Harmful Products
    • Prescription Drug Injuries
  • About Our Firm
    • DJ Giveaways
      • $2500 Charity Giveaway
      • Think Before U Drink
      • DJ Birthday Bash
    • Community Service
      • DJ WINS for Kansas
      • Helping Hand Grants
      • Pay it Forward
      • Veteran Salute – Topeka
      • Veteran Salute – Wichita
      • In The Community
    • Join Our Team
    • DeVaughn James Newsletter
    • FAQ’s
    • What Our Clients Say
    • Our Results
    • Tour Our Offices Online
  • Attorneys
    • Dustin L. DeVaughn
    • Richard W. James
    • Cody G. Claassen
    • Shawn P. Aldrich
    • Joseph Behzadi
    • Jessica A. Brunken
    • Joseph Bryden
    • Nick French
    • Andrew T. Geren
    • Garrett Heath
    • Tymber W. Long
    • Tim Love
    • Brendan P. Lykins
    • Andy Massey
    • Claire Melero
    • Scott Nading
    • Heather A. Nizzio
    • Chris Omlid
    • Mackenzie Orchard
    • Dakota Persinger
    • Arthur E. Rhodes
    • Lance Smith
    • Corey Sucher
    • Nicole Turner
    • Patrick Turner
    • Luke J. Williams
    • Jeff Wilson
  • Blog
  • Contact
    • East Wichita Office
    • West Wichita Office
    • Topeka Office
    • Attorney Referral
316-888-8888
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Car Accidents
  • Talking or Texting while driving – which is more dangerous?

Talking or Texting while driving – which is more dangerous?

Talking or Texting while driving – which is more dangerous?

by admin / Wednesday, February 13, 2019 / Published in Car Accidents, Motorcycle Accidents, Personal Injury, Safety Tips

Texting while driving leads you to take your eyes off the road, and the danger here is obvious. Most people believe that talking instead of texting or shifting to a hands-free device is enough to mitigate the risks. However, this simply is not the case. The shocking truth is that talking while driving is just as dangerous as texting; and no, using a hands-free device does not lower the risk.

 

Female driver talking on cell phone while driving

 

The numbers reveal the truth!

  • • According to the National Safety Council (NSC), nearly 25% of all car accidents in 2014 were attributed to cell phone usage.
  •  

  • • Only 5% of these mishaps involved texting.
  •  

  • • Annually, over 1.5 million crashes occur because of cell phone use while driving.
  •  

  • • A more recent study conducted by Cambridge Mobile Telematics (CMT) revealed that more than half of all auto accidents can be linked to cell phone distraction.
  •  

  • • In nearly 30% of these crashes, cell phone distractions happen when motorists are going above 56 mph.

 

 

In Kansas, 1 in 4 accidents can be linked to general inattentiveness. Statistics from KDOT implicated cell phone usage in just 1.2% of the crashes. But according to experts and the NSC, such figures are usually inaccurate because the majority of motorists involved in accidents don’t admit to using their cell phones.

 

Isn’t it just texting that poses the threat?

No! Talking on the phone when driving, whether the device used is handheld or hands-free is just as dangerous. However, the misconception that only texting leads to trouble, has led to a false sense of security and is possibly to be blamed for the increase in the number of cell phone-related road mishaps. Here are a few facts and figures that prove just that:

 

  1. In the statistics above, we know that only 5% of the accidents involved texting when driving. Let’s assume that another 5% are attributed to other forms of cell phone usage (music, GPS, etc…). This still leaves us with the other 15% of accidents that in all likelihood involved talking on the phone.
  2.  

  3. The NSC study also revealed that in most accidents involving cell phone use, the distraction that the device caused was for more than 2.3 minutes. The logical conclusion here is that the longer the duration of distraction, the greater the chance of an accident. Since people are likely to spend more time on a call than on a text message, it is easy to assume that talking greatly raises the risk of getting into a mishap.

 

If your hands are free, of course you are safe, right?

Not at all! This is another flawed assumption that contributes to the rising number of accidents on American roads. When driving, your attention matters as much as the use of both hands. This is supported in the figures in the NSC study. In states, where it is illegal to use a handheld phone when driving, the average device distraction time was found to be 3.17 minutes. States that don’t have laws against the use of handheld devices have average distraction time of 3.82 minutes. In both cases, the distraction time is well above 3 minutes, making the roads extremely dangerous for motorists.

 

Science proves that talking while driving is no less distracting!

A cognitive study to evaluate and compare the mental workload of talking and texting on the phone clarified this conclusion even further. The NSC reported the mental workload rating of using a cell phone in various ways while driving. Here are the figures:

 

  • • Talking on a handheld device: 2.45
  •  

  • • Talking on a hands-free device: 2.27
  •  

  • • Speech to texting applications: 3.06

 

As you can see, there isn’t a lot of difference in the level of distraction caused when talking on a handheld versus a hands-free device.

 

A report published in the Journal of Safety Research in 2009 was perhaps the first to shed light on the dangers of using hands-free phones while driving. It clearly stated that driving performance suffers just as much from the use of hands-free devices as it does through the use of handheld phones. In more recent years, the “Voice to Text Distraction Study” conducted by the Texas A&M Research Institute also led to this very conclusion.

 

Given this research, it is not just texting that you should be wary of. Any form of cell phone usage when driving is dangerous. If you want to be safe, switch off your phone or put it in the airplane mode while you are behind the wheel. The call or text can wait.

 

If you or a loved one has been in an accident caused by a distracted driver and you have suffered personal injury, it is your right to claim compensation for the recklessness of the other motorist.

 

Contact DeVaughn James Injury Lawyers and our team of experienced attorneys will seek the full compensation you deserve for your medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering.

 

References:

 

– Is a hands-free phone safer than a handheld phone?

 

– Voice-to-Text Driver Distraction Study

 

– NSC releases latest injury and fatality statistics and trends

 

– Distracted driving

 

– Distracted Driving Research, Infographics

  • Tweet
Tagged under: Car Accidents, Cell Phone use, Distracted Driving, Texting and Driving

What you can read next

Don’t Drink and Drive this Holiday Season
Safe Driving Tips for Fall Weather 2018
Motorcycle in city traffic near miss crash
Kansas Motorcycle accidents: 10 tips that prevent motorcycle crashes!

Recent Blog Posts

  • Semi-truck and car collision on Kansas roadway

    Motorists’ Rights After a Trucking Accident in Topeka, Kansas

    A trucking accident can be a devastating and li...
  • Become a Top Fan on Facebook for Our Exclusive Giveaways!

    You can earn a Top Fan badge by being one of th...
  • Young people drinking at a club on New Year's Eve.

    Kansas Residents Can Avoid Drunk Driving This New Year’s Eve

    Every New Year’s Eve, thousands of Kansas resid...
  • Car driving on Kansas winter road in snowy conditions.

    Winter Driving Tips for Kansas Residents or Travelers

    Driving in the winter can be risky, particularl...
  • Semi-truck and Car collide in busy intersection.

    Three Reasons to Hire a Kansas Truck Accident Lawyer

    Whether a truck rams into a car or a car into t...

Archives

Categories

  • Bicycle Accident
  • Car Accidents
  • Class Action
  • Commercial Vehicle Accidents
  • Community Service
  • Dog Bites
  • Firm News
  • Kansas Auto Insurance
  • Law
  • Motorcycle Accidents
  • Nursing Home Abuse
  • Personal Injury
  • Safety Tips
  • Slip & Fall Accidents
  • Trucking Accidents
  • Uncategorized
  • Veterans
  • Wrongful Death

ABOUT US

DeVaughn James Injury Lawyers is the largest personal injury law firm in Kansas. We have offices in Wichita and Topeka where we focus on personal injury cases, such as car accidents, semi-truck accidents, and wrongful death. Every day we help Kansans, just like you, who have suffered an injury through no fault of their own.

*No Fee Guarantee represents a contingent fee contract, the payment of an attorney fee is contingent on a recovery.

CONTACT US

316-888-8888
316-977-9999
785-888-8888
620-888-8888

*Prior results do not guarantee outcomes in future cases as each case is individually based upon the personal injuries of the clients.

24/7 LIVE CHAT AVAILABLE

24/7 Live Chat Service

*Offices located in Wichita & Topeka, Kansas. Proudly serving all of Kansas! DeVaughn James - East | DeVaughn James - West | DeVaughn James - Topeka

  • Home
  • Contact
  • Attorney Referral
  • DJ Newsletters
  • Join Our Team
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap

© 2023 DeVaughn James Injury Lawyers. All Rights Reserved.

TOP